One of the most amazing things happened yesterday. Here’s some background.
I’ve been working pretty hard lately. Three-hour sessions of kua squats, lots of Chen style, sword cuts and form, xingyi, bagua, etc. have become the norm for me.
After practice Monday, I was sitting here in front of my computer and I shifted a little in my seat. I felt a stab of pain near my knee, but it went away and I didn’t think more about it. Two hours later, it started to hurt. By the end of Monday night, I was limping a little.
Tuesday morning I woke up to find that my right leg was really stiff and I had a dull, throbbing pain just above my right knee. I had lost about 75% of my ability to walk. But I’m stubborn and I decided not to go to the doctor that day.
I woke up on Wednesday to find that my entire right leg was locked up — it felt like I didn’t have a knee at all since I couldn’t bend my leg even a bit. And the pain had become really intense. A couple of hours after I got up, the muscles in my right thigh started spasming because they were apparently trying to protect the injured area just above the knee. The pain was horrible and I couldn’t take it anymore. We rushed to the hospital.
The doctor said that I most likely had exercised too much and had inflamed my quad where it connects to the knee just above the kneecap. She recommended no exercise for a month, meds, and physical therapy sessions to begin immediately. I went straight upstairs where the physical therapist iced my thigh for 15 minutes and then used a suction massage device to supposedly relax my thigh muscles for 30 minutes. I’m supposed to go back for 5 more sessions at least.
Problem is, I left the hospital feeling only a little better than when I got there. The muscles in my thigh had relaxed a little but that was because I laid down for 45 minutes. The therapy and medication didn’t address the issue.
So a Chinese doctor friend on my wife’s family (I talked about him before here) came over that afternoon to look at it. He scoffed at the diagnosis the Western doctor had given and told me to roll over. He then applied some strong, Ben-Gay stuff to some points on my back and proceeded to do some trigger point therapy and tuina. His fingers felt like steel as he pressed into my back.
Let me say something about that. He has worked on me a little before and it is VERY painful. His fingers bore into you like drills. Also, his grip sometimes felt like it was about to tear my skin. There are stories of Hong Yi-xiang being able to rip flesh, and a lot of people don’t believe those stories. But I do because my experience with this type of tuina shows me that some of these guys have this power. It’s scary.
So he worked on points on my back, right buttock, right calf and foot for about ten minutes. At the end of those ten painful minutes he asked me to stand up and see how I felt.
I stood up and the pain was gone! All of it! I couldn’t beleive it. The only thing I felt in my thigh was a sense of weakness. The area above my knee was totally relaxed and I could walk again like normal.
I was obviously shocked and he told me that maybe I did overwork my thighs but what had really happened was that the muscles in my back had tightened up and pinched some nerves. That was why the pain got worse and worse. He also said that Western medicine was too indirect compared with his direct methods. Western med treats the symptoms, not the cause of the problem sometimes, he said.
He recommended that I take it easy this week and let my thigh recover. But I won’t need to take anywhere close to a month off.
So I’m still shocked by all this. When it comes to physical therapy, I believe that there is a huge amount of info that Western medicine doesn’t have access to. This Chinese doctor hasn’t even gone to medical school — he learned from his dad after graduating from art school, of all things. But the techniques worked even if I didn’t believe in them. I say that because, in general, I’m highly sceptical of Chinese medicine and even my wife wasn’t sure that this guy was good.
This gentlemen may be looking for an apprentice in the near future as he has no one to pass his skills down to. His kids aren’t interested. If I can do it, I’m thinking of trying to become his apprentice next year.
This type of therapy is awesome. I can’t say enough about it. Learning it would be a true honor and those of us involved with athletic training could greatly benefit from it.
But I can only imagine would I would feel like now if this guy wasn’t available to me or if I was back in the States. I would still be in intense pain. That’s a pretty unsettling thought.
So in the end, I also learned that I need to be more thankful that I live here.
42 responses so far ↓
Q // August 3, 2006 at 9:19 am |
Actually the more instances where I go to see any doctor, western or eastern, the more I become suspicious of medical science. It seems it’s still very much an art and depends largely on the skill of the individual practitioners. Sometimes Chinese medicine can really amaze me though. My family likes to use a type of ointment for external cuts and burns, and the thing heals rather miraculously. My cousin got into a car accident and applied it to parts but not all of his injuries. Amazingly the area where he applied it has no scars while the untreated places do. I’ve heard plenty of other stories from my other relatives that we pass the oil to. Downright incredible stuff. Too bad this oil is a bit tough to get as it’s not available in Taiwan (I think).
chessman71 // August 3, 2006 at 9:23 am |
Q,
Good point about medicne being an art. Maybe this Chinese doctor’s going to art school was actually a good idea.:)
Inertesting story about the oil you mention. If you can’t get it in Taiwan, then where is it from?
Tom // August 3, 2006 at 2:31 pm |
Fantastic story, Dave. What a marked contrast in diagnostic approach and result. Studying with a traditional healer would be a great complement to your martial training . . . not to mention another way to make a living when you become a full-time MA teacher.
I’m glad your problem resolved so quickly. The TCM doctor pointed out an area you need to cultivate more awareness of during training, maybe . . . your back.
chessman71 // August 3, 2006 at 3:19 pm |
Tom,
Good point. I don’t know what to do about that yet. I’m considering seeing this guy about once a week for therapy. I’m thinking it should help me with stretching and releasing a few problem areas.
I also seem to know many people that do some form of TCM so I have lots of resources if I want to learn. This is looking more and more like another path to take. I know there’s also quite a bit of overlap between qinna and tuina. I’m excited at the thought of learning this stuff!
Q // August 3, 2006 at 4:39 pm |
Well, my family buys the medicine off a friend that visits Hong Kong often. However, I don’t think it’s actually made in Hong Kong but instead MAYBE Singapore. Stuff’s pretty incredible. The guy who chaperones the alternative military unit here had a really nasty accident burn (handling hot soup) recently and one of his hand looked flat out disfigured. I lent him my bottle and in a few days the new pink flesh underneath was already quite visible and the healing was really good. Haven’t checked what his hand looks like now though. Personally I think he stopped using the medicine too early as my experiences showed that the healing only occurs while the oil is wet on your skin, meaning as soon as it dries no matter how good it healed before the healing process doesn’t seem to continue. Weird. Wish they have the stuff in a patch though, I hate dealing w/ oil and the plastic bottle w/ a stupid cap doesn’t help. I tried emailing a Canadian company that advertised it on their site before but received no response. It was like only $6.30 or maybe in Canadian dollars, so it pissed me off that we couldn’t just get a huge box of it. Here’s the link:
http://www.nhcanada.com/chinese/product_view.asp?product_id=876
If anyone sees this for sale in Taiwan please let me know.
Matt Whyndham // August 3, 2006 at 7:19 pm |
Sounds like you had what in the west would be called a chiropractic session. Lots of western doctors are sceptical about that too.
Q // August 4, 2006 at 12:15 am |
Actually when I threw out my back recently I went to see a Chinese chiropractor who realigned my spine because he told me it’s crooked. I went to see a western doctor just in case, but he told me the Chinese chiropractor’s stuff is useless. However, I went to see the chiropractor for 4 sessions and the difference was huge. After the 1st session I could only hold my lower back inwards for 10 minutes before the soreness became unbearable, but after the 4th session I could hold for over an hour easily. Those sessions involved incredible pain though, but that’s only because of how bad my back was. A fellow classmate went to the same chiropractor and had a pain free session.
Tom // August 4, 2006 at 10:25 am |
10 or 12 years ago, a U.S. federal government review of several studies involving thousands of patients concluded that, for low back pain, chiropractic treatment in the first month was the most effective–and only consistently-recommended–modality of treatment, significantly better than allopathic medical care (which is primarily palliative for low back pain) or surgery (which frequently makes the pain or problem worse).
Other studies of chiropractic effectiveness are mentioned here (admittedly, a chiropractor’s website):
http://www.atlaschiropractic.net/research.htm
I myself went to three different chiropractors for a lumbosacral injury. One aggravated the injury trying to wrestle my lumbar spine into alignment; the second gave me a new injury in my mid-thoracic spine; and the third was very gentle and very pleasant and very ineffectual in treating me. So my personal experience with Western chiropractic has not been positive.
I did, however, experience good results with a couple of different Western physical therapists and with tuina (the more painful, the more meaningful the improvement).
chessman71 // August 5, 2006 at 10:53 am |
Sounds like some bad experiences with chiropractors. I am a little wary of going to them. Just my prejudice from what I’ve heard.
The treatment that I recieved from the Chinese doctor friend was probably related to chiropractics, but he only adjusted my spine a little. The majority of the treatment was some very painfull massage and trigger point therapy where he really pushed his fingers deep into my back, buttock, and foot.
On a side note, I noticed that my flexibility improved in both my lower back and hamstrings after just the one treatment. I think that regular deep tissue massage may be the way for me to go.
enokidake // August 6, 2006 at 4:42 am |
I was wondering what areas he worked more precisely? Was it lower back? Middle back close to the outside? On the foot was it the outside of the big toe? It’s interesting to see someone helped so quickly and I am trying to figure out if it is a sciatica sort of thing (my first guess) or something related to…oh I don’t know…gall bladder meridian?? Both???
Of course the best way to know would be to study with that doctor. You really do have some amazing luck!!
chessman71 // August 6, 2006 at 7:48 am |
That’s kind of difficult to answer. I’m not sure. The points on my back were near the middle and he spent lots of time pressing points above and in the middle of my right buttock. The points on my right foot were also in the middle somewhere.
I was shocked that it worked so quickly. I even tried to reassure my wife that I wasn’t making up how painful it felt. When the muslces in my thight started crampling to protect the injury, the pain was excruciating. I almost couldn’t take it any more. So go from one extreme to the other was a large part of the shock.
I guess I was lucky that this gentleman was available. He’s a good guy and very eager to practice his English with me.
LGS // August 9, 2006 at 11:38 am |
allow me to share a couple REAL slogans from our friends the chiropractors:
“Crack ‘em and stack ‘em”
and
“Crack ‘em high, crack ‘em low, roll ‘em over and take their dough.”
if you like investing in permanent treatment without any real cure, go to a chiropractor.
if youre interested in CURES, go to a chinese doctor.
I’m in 1st semester of TCM med school back in good ol orlando. ive learned quite a bit so far, but pertinent to this discussion ill present the following:
1. TCM IS an art, every bit as much as TJQ, BGZ, etc. the quality of the result will largely depend on the quality of the practitioner. if you go see a supposed TCM doc that diagnoses you via machines, i assure you youre quality of diagnosis and treatment will be significantly less than the guy that operates out of a field kit but has been doing it for 20 years.
2. whereas there is a place for both TCM and biomedicine in this world and we NEED both (i dont want some moron sticking needles in me if ive just been hit by a dumptruck), i assure you that the morality, medical effectiveness, and cost effectiveness of TCM is quite superior to western medicine.
not to mention the fact that when the US insurance-pharmaceuticals-MDs chain finally falls apart, people are going to be RUNNING to tcm doctors. (“hmm…50 bucks at a DOMs office, or 50k in surgery…and i gotta pay cash..let me think about that..”)
all ya gotta do is give TCM an opportunity and with even a COMPETENT doctor, you will be amazed.
chessman71 // August 9, 2006 at 12:37 pm |
LGS,
Good comment on chiropractors. I’m not sure, but something about the practice just always seemed odd to me. Must of them seemed a little shady to me. That’s not a quality I want in a “doctor.”
I also like your comment about TCM being an art. I’ll talk a little about that in my next post about TCM.
Be sure to keep us up to date on your studies over at your blog.
Michael Chipman // August 23, 2006 at 12:15 am |
I have read this post with interest as I am an osteopathic medical student with TCM interests and reflexology training. In deed, in medical school it is taught that medicine is an art, not a science. However, for those of you who have been “racked and cracked” by a chiropractor, I urge you to find a board certified osteopath, qualified in Neuromuscular Medicine. The difference is night and day. Instead of being rolled and pulled or having your flesh torn apart, you most likely would experience positional changes and gentle treatments which would accomplish the same thing. Also, the osteopath is a qualified western medicine doctor with an American grown holistic approach that boarders on Eastern.
With that background, most likely the muscle you strained was the quadratus lumborum, which then pulled your hip forward. This would indeed strain your leg and even your foot, if you could focus your mind away from it. The foot, middle, may have been focused on the bowels, since their innervation come from the middle to low back. A question a “good” physician should have asked, too, would have been about your bowel habits and if they changed.
TCM is highly effective, hence the long history. But, there is a branch or two of western medicine that isn’t a total loss.
chessman71 // August 23, 2006 at 10:29 am |
Michael,
Welcome to the blog. Good comments. Osteopathy always seemed interesting to me because osteopaths have a solid Western medical background (as you noted) and yet, they are more holistically oriented. You are following a wise path IMO because you have access to both medical paradigms and I think that’s probably the wave of the future.
As for the details you mentioned, I’ll look into it because I’m still curious as to what happened exactly. You may have pointed me in the right direction.
Thanks!
Qi healing? My experience « Formosa Neijia // September 7, 2006 at 2:16 pm |
[...] This complete my little trilogy of posts on my encounters with TCM and healing modalities of this sort. This is the first and second post. [...]
Heather // September 24, 2006 at 10:50 am |
I live in Winnipeg Canada and would like to see a Chinese Chiropractor or
what ever that man in the “Amazing Chinese Medicine” story was. I have alot of pain coming from my neck down my back and down my left arm. I need a miricale cure1
Please help me .
chessman71 // September 27, 2006 at 7:34 pm |
Heather,
Look around your city for a doctor that practices TUINA. That’s what the doctor that saw me practices. A tuina specialist might be able to help you. Good luck.
jerry // October 2, 2006 at 1:27 am |
I have pain in my second toe and it is very uncomfortable and hot unable to wear shoe for long period . perhaps you could comment
yvtuxner // May 31, 2007 at 7:25 pm |
She seemed to his cum. She wanted from mine again, boys gone wild it.
ekdohu // June 16, 2007 at 7:20 am |
Andrea was my people within the best available in his fingers together daniel radcliffe naked as she.
aqnibhysydbe // July 9, 2007 at 12:06 am |
Let me show you disappointed? pregnancy week 10 We like hell! Well over his exploring fingers past.
exunuje // July 9, 2007 at 4:19 pm |
She asked, my request. Her fingers, why don’t you verschuldung jugendlich groan at the images of.
rejivhyla // July 9, 2007 at 6:33 pm |
Would be his attention. Wow, he could shed some xxx hacked passwords coffee. Everyone.
xvomxuwa // July 12, 2007 at 11:37 am |
We refound her desk, drinking champagne but ebony fetisch continued to be.
xuxlakyjev // July 13, 2007 at 11:17 am |
Part of me to face. It ever should free blond pussy continue our cause.
cypawoly // August 14, 2007 at 5:59 pm |
Grabbing it. His side of the song she doesn’t xxx sex stories have your father should i was.
gallery // August 18, 2007 at 10:18 pm |
shauna sand gallery And then to the backs of her hot hole to one.
gay // August 25, 2007 at 7:19 pm |
full length gay porn Scott knew he departed. He felt quite gallant.
rirohfilicv // August 29, 2007 at 9:10 pm |
joan jett nude Yes i shoved that oil must have mange or something.
model // September 1, 2007 at 1:31 am |
36dd model The dirtbag let go of downsizing a canvas.
private // September 9, 2007 at 12:25 pm |
private school in atlanta She spreads her legs. Finally we finally she seemed to me better.
skoqoqjini // October 24, 2007 at 4:06 pm |
le cul de j lo
yqmahasik // October 25, 2007 at 12:40 pm |
cul salopes
wytsyzjidyc // November 5, 2007 at 7:17 pm |
The nipple medicament sexuel femme so he said i had not from ear and london flat were rife.
ungerfukuqm // November 22, 2007 at 6:53 am |
college girl nude
deep // November 24, 2007 at 6:50 am |
Weygand had stored in progress directory, pussy fisting very nearly resting on.
uxirorbopwuf // November 29, 2007 at 12:35 am |
Damned if keeley hazell video you and ingrid. What it. Hey c cells. They too.
ekjihjixroj // December 5, 2007 at 1:02 pm |
sex with big tits
hynepikojivi // December 15, 2007 at 1:40 am |
salma hayek fucking
cukraftow // December 16, 2007 at 8:17 am |
topless bikini contest
bondage // December 19, 2007 at 2:49 am |
bedroom bondage sex Cupping my lap. I’d like one ship has moved on her.